The Chosen Cast Admit Their True Faith: 2026 Update

One of the most compelling aspects of *The Chosen*, the popular series depicting the life of Jesus, is the diversity of its cast’s faith backgrounds. While their dedication to the show might suggest they’re all Christian, the reality is far more varied.

This diversity underscores the show’s unique ability to unite people across different beliefs, proving its universal appeal. Let’s explore the spiritual perspectives of key cast members and how their backgrounds influence their roles.

**Jonathan Roumie (Jesus)**, as many might guess, identifies as a born-again Catholic. Baptized Greek Orthodox, he now emphasizes daily gratitude to God for his blessings, stating, “I take nothing for granted and am grateful to be here.”

His commitment shines through in his habit of seeking the nearest Catholic church when traveling, reflecting a deep personal faith. Playing Jesus is more than a role for him; it’s a profound responsibility, and he’s admitted to struggling with feeling worthy of it, showcasing his devotion.

**Vanessa Benavidez (Mary, Mother of Jesus)** delivers a captivating performance that might assume Christian faith, yet her beliefs remain ambiguous. Speculation ranges from agnosticism to other traditions, but she hasn’t labeled herself publicly.

When asked about portraying Mary without a confirmed Christian identity, she focused on the character’s strengths, devotion, and faith as sources of inspiration. Her sincere and respectful approach to the role speaks volumes, regardless of her personal stance.

**Shahar Isaac (Simon Peter)**, born and raised in Israel from an Israeli Yemenite Jewish background, brings cultural authenticity to his character. A rumored quote calling the characters “mythological” circulated online, but without a verified source, it’s unclear if it reflects his views. Context matters, so assumptions should be avoided until confirmed.

**Noah James (Andrew)**, Shahar’s real-life best friend on set and also Jewish, finds personal resonance in his role. Filming scenes like the Sermon on the Mount felt powerful, connecting him deeply to the story.

He’s noted that his Jewish heritage adds authenticity to his performance, and during intense Season 4 moments, learning to surrender helped him manage challenging scenes.

**Elizabeth Tabish (Mary Magdalene)** openly shares her faith journey, admitting to skepticism during dark times but recognizing God’s constant presence in hindsight.

She critiques how faith often intertwines with politics, noting that many liberal Christians feel overshadowed by conservative assumptions. As a self-described “hardcore leftist” and Christian, she believes Jesus championed the marginalized, motivating her to speak out.

**Paras Patel (Matthew)**, raised Hindu, keeps his current beliefs private. However, playing Matthew—portrayed as on the autism spectrum—has given him purpose.

He’s expressed gratitude for inspiring others through the role, calling it a “once-in-a-lifetime experience,” suggesting a spiritual connection, though his specific faith remains unclear.

**David Amito**, who isn’t Christian, sparked debate with a 2020 Instagram post about a horror film trending over Jesus at Easter. After clarifying it as a joke and stating he doesn’t believe in the devil, he praised *The Chosen* as a beautiful, respectful experience.

Ultimately, mutual respect and dedication to the craft unite this diverse cast, proving that shared purpose transcends personal beliefs.